When Good News Hurts: Navigating the Longing of Reproductive Grief

The Language of Longing

As a second-generation Portuguese American, there is a word that has come to resonate with me as I've gotten older: Saudade.

It's one of those words that can be difficult to translate directly into English, and its meaning can be interpreted in different ways. Trust me, spend enough time online and you'll find no shortage of debates about what it really means, whether it can be translated, and who gets to define it. Often described as a deep, bittersweet longing for someone or something absent, saudade carries an emotional depth that goes beyond simply missing something.

I don't have a definitive answer, and I don't think I need one. My connection to the word is personal, which may be part of what makes it meaningful.

So, when I think about reproductive grief and the particular kind of longing that can accompany it, I find myself returning to saudade.

It might be longing for a pregnancy you lost, a child you hoped to have, or an experience you imagined would be part of your life. It might be longing for the version of yourself who hadn't yet experienced loss, or for the future you once pictured so clearly.

Sometimes, you're missing something you once had. Other times, you're grieving something you've never had but have spent so much time hoping for.

And sometimes, you may not know exactly what you're longing for. You just know that something hurts.

When Someone Else's Happiness Brings Your Own Grief to the Surface

There are certain moments when someone else's happiness can bring you face-to-face with your own heartache.

For those navigating reproductive grief, it might happen when a friend shares their pregnancy news, a family member sends an ultrasound photo, or a coworker announces that they're expecting. What is intended as a joyful moment can unexpectedly bring feelings of sadness, longing, or loss to the surface.

You might find yourself smiling, offering congratulations, and asking questions while simultaneously feeling disconnected from the excitement everyone else seems to be sharing. You may genuinely wish them well, but find that beneath your congratulations is a sadness that is difficult to put into words.

And then, suddenly, comes the guilt.

Why can't I just be happy for them?

What's wrong with me?

Why does this still hurt so much?

If you've experienced pregnancy loss, infertility, unsuccessful IVF cycles, recurrent miscarriage, or the realization that having a child may not be possible for you, these moments can carry a weight that others may not fully recognize.

And there is nothing wrong with you for finding them difficult.

A pregnancy announcement might remind you of the pregnancy you lost. A baby shower might bring you back to the months or years you've spent hoping for a child. Meeting a friend's newborn might stir up questions about whether you'll ever have that experience yourself.

Sometimes, it's not even about a particular pregnancy or baby.

It's about what that moment represents.

The family you imagined. The experiences you hoped to have. The milestones you thought you would share with friends or family at the same stage of life.

You Can Be Happy for Someone and Sad for Yourself

One of the more difficult aspects of these experiences can be the belief that your emotions have to make sense together.

You might think:

If I'm truly happy for my friend, why am I crying after her pregnancy announcement?

If I love my sister, why am I dreading her baby shower?

If I've accepted that IVF may not work, why does hearing about someone else's pregnancy still hurt?

If I'm grateful for the life I have, why do I still feel so sad about the family I imagined?

We sometimes treat emotions as though they are mutually exclusive, as though feeling one thing means we cannot genuinely feel another.

But emotions don't work that way.

You can love your friend and feel jealous of her pregnancy. You can be excited to meet your new niece or nephew and grieve the pregnancy you lost. You can genuinely wish someone well while also wishing things had turned out differently for yourself.

You can celebrate someone else's joy without having to set aside your own sadness. These feelings don't cancel each other out. They can coexist.

Experiencing jealousy, resentment, or anger doesn't make you a bad friend, partner, sibling, or person. Often, these emotions are connected to something much more tender underneath: longing, grief, disappointment, and the pain of wanting something deeply.

Reproductive Grief Doesn't Look the Same for Everyone

There isn't one universal experience of reproductive grief, and there isn't one predictable emotional response to pregnancy announcements or new babies.

For someone navigating infertility, a pregnancy announcement may feel like another reminder of how unfair and unpredictable the process can be. You might wonder why it seems so easy for others when you've spent months or years attending appointments, undergoing procedures, waiting for results, and managing the uncertainty of what comes next.

For someone who has experienced pregnancy loss, hearing about another person's pregnancy may bring back memories of their own. Even when you have begun to heal, someone else's announcement can unexpectedly bring those feelings to the surface again.

For someone who has experienced recurrent pregnancy loss, the excitement surrounding pregnancy may be accompanied by fear, uncertainty, and memories of previous losses.

For someone who has undergone IVF or other fertility treatments, an announcement might bring up the emotional and physical exhaustion of a journey that others may never fully understand. You may feel happy for someone while also remembering everything it took, and everything you may still be facing, to try to build your own family.

Even when you already have a child, struggling to grow your family can bring its own grief, particularly when the family you imagined looks different from the one you're able to have.

And for someone who has come to understand that biological parenthood, or parenthood altogether, may not be part of their future, these moments can carry a different kind of grief. It may be grief for a future that once felt possible, for an identity you imagined, or for a life that looks different from the one you expected.

There is no timeline for these feelings, and no requirement that you eventually reach a place where pregnancy announcements and baby celebrations no longer affect you.

How to Cope With Pregnancy Announcements and Baby Showers

Sometimes, taking care of yourself means recognizing that you don't have the emotional capacity to participate in every celebration or conversation.

You might decide not to attend a baby shower. You might mute someone's pregnancy updates on social media. You might ask a family member to share pregnancy news with you privately rather than in a large group. You might need some time before visiting someone and their new baby.

These decisions don't have to be punishments or statements about how you feel toward someone else. They can simply be ways of acknowledging what you need.

You are allowed to make choices that protect your emotional well-being.

If you aren't sure what to say, you might try:

"I'm really happy for you. I'm also navigating some difficult feelings right now, so I may need a little time."

"I care about you and want to celebrate with you. I might not be able to participate in everything, but I hope you understand."

"I'm having a harder time with pregnancy and baby-related conversations than I expected. It helps when I can have a little warning before these conversations come up."

You don't owe everyone an explanation, either. Sometimes it's enough to simply say that you're unable to attend or that you need a little space.

Making Room for the Feelings That Follow

For many people, the sadness itself isn't the only difficult part. It's the judgment that follows.

You might replay a conversation and feel guilty that you weren't more enthusiastic. You might feel ashamed of the jealousy you experienced. You might worry that your sadness makes you selfish or that you're somehow taking away from someone else's happiness.

But having a difficult emotional response doesn't mean you wish someone else harm. It doesn't mean you aren't supportive, and it certainly doesn't mean you aren't capable of loving the people around you.

It means you're having a human response to something that hurts.

Rather than asking yourself why you can't just be happy, it may be helpful to ask:

What did this moment bring up for me?

What am I grieving or longing for right now?

What do I need in this moment?

Am I judging myself for having feelings that I would readily understand in someone else?

You don't have to turn every difficult feeling into a lesson or immediately find a way to make it better. Sometimes, allowing yourself to acknowledge the feeling without judging it is enough.

There Is Room for Both

One of the hardest things about reproductive grief is that the spinning rock we all find ourselves standing on will continue to spin, regardless of our pain.

Friends get pregnant. Families grow. Birthdays and holidays come around. People share milestones that may feel increasingly distant from your own experience.

It can sometimes feel as though everyone else is moving through a chapter of life that you desperately want to be part of, while you're left navigating a story you never expected to have.

And yet, you can care deeply about the people around you while acknowledging that their experiences sometimes hurt to witness.

You can wish someone a healthy pregnancy and still cry when you get home. You can hold a newborn and feel both tenderness and sadness. You can be genuinely happy for someone and still wish, more than anything, that things had been different for you.

You don't have to make your grief smaller to make room for someone else's happiness.

And you don't have to feel guilty for the moments when someone else's good news reminds you of your own heartache.

There is room for both.

Finding Support for Reproductive Grief

If these experiences are bringing up feelings that are difficult to navigate, you don't have to work through them alone. Infertility, pregnancy loss, and the uncertainty of family building can affect many parts of your emotional well-being, including relationships, identity, and how you envision your future.

Working with a therapist who understands reproductive and perinatal mental health can offer a space to process these experiences without judgment, make room for complicated emotions, and explore ways to care for yourself along the way.

You deserve support, not just during the most difficult moments of your journey, but in the quieter moments when grief unexpectedly finds its way back in.

Additional Resources

If you're navigating infertility, pregnancy loss, or reproductive grief, connecting with others who understand these experiences can be incredibly meaningful. RESOLVE: The National Infertility Association offers resources and community support for individuals navigating infertility and family-building challenges. Postpartum Support International provides support and resources for pregnancy and infant loss, while Share Pregnancy & Infant Loss Support offers peer support, educational resources, and opportunities to connect with others who have experienced loss. Whatever your experience looks like, you deserve to feel supported and understood.

Next
Next

A Love Letter to Parents During a Heavy Time…